Young Scholars Series: Jillian Rose Roberts

The Saul Kripke Center is pleased to announce that Jillian Rose Roberts (PhD student, Philosophy, CUNY Graduate Center) will deliver the fifth Saul Kripke Center Young Scholars Series talk on Friday, September 11, 2020, from 1:00 to 3:00 pm (NY time) via Zoom. (This talk was previously scheduled for March 24, 2020.) The talk is free and open to all, but those interested in attending should email the Saul Kripke Center in advance to register.

Title: The Adoption Problem in Logic: Devitt’s Flawed Quinean Solution

Abstract: Can we adopt a new logic? If so, how? In unpublished talks, Saul Kripke has presented a certain message about this that Romina Padro has vigorously defended in What the Tortoise Said to Kripke—the Adoption Problem (2015). Padro contends certain basic logical principles cannot be adopted: “if a subject already infers in accordance with basic logical principles, no adoption is needed, and if the subject does not infer in accordance with them, no adoption is…possible.” Michael Devitt has taken up Kripke and Padro’s challenge in an unpublished paper, “The Adoption Problem in Logic: A Quinean Picture” (2016). Devitt argues for a Quinean solution to the adoption problem, concluding it is possible in principle for someone who does not reason by basic inferences to come to do so as a result of adopting the basic logical principles and training. I simply ask—does his solution work? I contend that Devitt’s attempted solution is critically flawed in a way that sheds new light on the problem.